Most trademark owners know the first way to lose a registration: miss a maintenance deadline. Fewer know the second, and it’s the one I’m seeing more often. You can lose part or all of your registration for claiming goods and services you never actually sold.
For non-trademark lawyers, the conventional wisdom was to list everything. Shirts, hats, bags, mugs, software, consulting, “and related goods.” If you might sell it someday, put it in. Filing mills and DIY platforms still push this. It felt like free protection, but it’s a liability because the USPTO now checks, and anyone can challenge your registration to get it out of the way.
The Audit Program
When you file the maintenance declaration between years five and six, or the renewal every ten years, the USPTO can randomly select your registration for audit. If it does, you’ll get an office action asking for proof of use on specific goods or services in your registration, beyond the one specimen you submitted.
Can’t prove you’re actually selling that item? It gets deleted, and you pay a fee for each class where goods are removed (currently $250 per class). Can’t prove use on anything in a class? The whole class goes. The USPTO has issued nearly 36,000 audit actions since the program started, and almost half of the audited registrations ended up deleting goods, services, or entire classes. More than 5,000 registrations were canceled outright.
Those aren’t fraud cases. Most of those owners were represented by attorneys. They simply claimed more than they could back up.
Expungement and Reexamination: The Competitor’s Tool
The audit is random. The second mechanism is not. Under the Trademark Modernization Act, anyone can file a petition asking the USPTO to strip goods and services from a registration for nonuse. There are two flavors:
- Expungement: The mark has never been used on some or all of the listed goods. Available from three to ten years after registration.
- Reexamination: The mark wasn’t in use on the listed goods when the owner swore it was, at filing or at the statement of use. Available for the first five years.
These are cheaper and faster than a full cancellation proceeding before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, and the petitioner doesn’t have to be a party to anything. A competitor who wants your name, a company that got refused because of your registration, or a would-be applicant who searched you and found a bloated goods list can all file. If the USPTO finds a case, the burden shifts to you to prove use, item by item.
Why the “Kitchen Sink” Filing Backfires
An overbroad registration used to look strong. Now it’s a target. Every good you can’t document is an opening, and every deletion narrows the protection you thought you had. Worse, if you signed a declaration of use covering goods you knew weren’t in use, you’ve created a fraud argument that can put the entire registration at risk, not just the padded parts. The USPTO’s crackdown on filing mills and fabricated specimens has made examiners far less forgiving of sloppy evidence.
What to Do Now
- Audit yourself first. Pull each registration and go line by line. For every good or service, ask, “Are we selling this in U.S. commerce right now, and can I show it?”
- Keep dated specimens for every class. Screenshots of product pages with the mark and a buy button, photos of labeled products, service ads. Save them with dates, every year, not just at filing time.
- Delete before you’re asked. Voluntarily removing unused goods before the maintenance filing is free. Removing them in response to an audit is not.
- File in stages. Register what you sell now. When you expand, file a new application. It costs more than one bloated filing, but it holds up.
- Check your competitors’ registrations too. If someone’s overbroad registration is blocking your name, this cuts both ways.
Your registration is only as strong as the use behind it. If you’d like us to review your portfolio before the USPTO or a competitor does, call us today at (888) 666-0062 or click here to schedule your initial Discovery and Strategy Session online.
DISCLAIMER: The information contained in this article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice or a substitute for obtaining legal advice from an attorney.